5.5 C
New York
Saturday, March 2, 2024

InfiRay P2 Pro and TOPDON TC001 Thermal Cameras Capsule Review

InfiRay P2 Pro and TOPDON TC001 Thermal Cameras Capsule Review

The consumer thermal camera market was opened up in the late 2010s by the launch of Seek Thermal’s first offering and FLIR’s FLIR ONE / FLIR ONE Pro. These had comparatively high resolutions of 206×156 and 160×120, which allowed the companies to further cut down the cost of follow-up products with lower-resolution sensors. US regulations prevent these cameras from offering videos with frame rates higher than 9 Hz, but that is often plenty enough for a wide variety of consumer use-cases such as home inspection (both electrical and plumbing), rodent control etc. The last couple of years have seen a new crop of thermal cameras from Asian vendors that don’t seem to be subject to frame rate limitations. Two vendors – InfiRay and TOPDON – reached out with review samples of their consumer-focused smartphone-attachable thermal cameras. This capsule review provides a comparative look at the features of the InfiRay P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001, with a focus on the user experience aspect.

Introduction and Product Impressions

InfiRay is the brand name under which products manufactured by IRay Technology Co. are being marketed. The company has been in operation for the last decade and claims many patents related to thermal imaging. The company designs and manufactures its own thermal imaging sensors using microbolometer infrared focal plane array technology. The basics of microbolometer sensors have already been covered in our previous thermal camera reviews, and is not being repeated here.

The P2 Pro is an ultra-compact smartphone-attachable thermal imager with a 256×192 resolution. It sports a Type-C male interface, and measures just 9g in weight. The temperature measurement range is from -4F to 1112F. It can record videos at up to 25 Hz. InfiRay claims an operational power consumption of less than 400 mW. The product also includes a magnetic macro lens that allows thermal investigation of minute components such as those on a circuit board. An extension cable (Type-C female to Type-C male) is also provided for flexibility in image capture.

TOPDON is a vendor of automotive equipment including ADAS packages, battery tools, EV chargers, and diagnostic tools (including thermal cameras). It is much larger than the InfiRay P2 Pro, but has the same IR resolution of 256×192. It weighs 30g, and measures 71mm x 42mm x 14mm. The temperature measurement range is from -4F to 1022F. Included in the package is a 50cm USB cable with a Type-C female port at one end, and a Type-C male with an attached Type-C female to Type-A male adapter.

While both the P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001 have their own Android applications, TOPDON also provides the Windows-based TCView application for image / video capture and analysis.

Smartphone-Attached Thermal Cameras Specifications
AspectInfiRay P2 ProTOPDON TC001FLIR ONE ProSeek Thermal CompactPRO
Resolution256 x 192256 x 192160 x 120320 x 240
Pixel Size12um12um12umstres
Noise-Equivalent Thermal Difference40mK @ 25C40mK @ 25C70mK70mK
Spectral Band8-14um8-14um8-14um7.5-14um
Frame Rate25 Hz25 Hz8.7 Hz< 9 Hz
Power Consumption350 mW350 mW~2000 mW280 mW
FoV56° x 42.2°N/A55° x 43°32°
Temperature Measurement Range-20C – 550C-20C – 550C-20C – 400C-40C – 330C
Temperature Measurement Accuracymax(+/-2C, +/-2%)max(+/-2C, +/-2%)max(+/-3C, +/-5%)max(+/-5C, +/-5%)
Case Dimensions27mm x 18mm x 9.8mm71mm x 42mm x 14mm68mm x 34mm x 14mm25.4mm x 44.5mm x 25.4mm
Price$250 – $300$230$280$413$474

The core technical specifications of both the InfiRay P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001 are very similar. The table above presents a comparative view of the P2 Pro and the TC001 against other cameras targeting similar market segments.

Application Interfaces and Sample Images

The InfiRay P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001 identify themselves as USB cameras when connected to a PC. The vendor and device identifiers point to a Realtek bridge chip / microcontroller in the package. The units generate 256×384 streams, and the actual image data is 256×192 (which can be viewed through programs like guvcview on Ubuntu). The other 256×192 stream is the temperature data.

Open-source software based on a reverse-engineered version of the image structure is also available for viewing live feeds from these thermal cameras. We put that to test and found that it managed to provide insight into the data from the cameras without having to install any closed-source software.

We are currently working on extending the software to be able to read and put out actionable information from photos and videos recorded using the respective smartphone applications.

The galleries below present some screenshots of the InfiRay P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001 Android apps

Since the internal platforms for both thermal cameras are the same, it is no surprise that the different menu options all end up configuring the same aspects. In general, we found the TOPDON TC001 app to be more intuitive, while the P2 Pro had most options hidden away under sub-menus. Overall, both applications allowed clear visualization of temperature gradients.

The image and video quality, as well as temperature readings for the same scenes, were similar for both the P2 Pro and the TC001. Some sample images are presented in the above galleries. We also captured some videos and they kept up with the advertised frame rates, except for the periodic calibration durations.

The P2 Pro’s macro lens does enable a differentiation – it is possible to take close-up pictures of PCBs under operation similar to the one above.

Concluding Remarks

The InfiRay P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001 use the same thermal imaging sensor, but target different market segments. The TOPDON TC001 is a bit more bulky, but comes with a more flexible extension cable and associated software interface. The availability of a Windows program to interface with the TC001 is a big plus for automotive repair shops, as most of them run other related software on that platform. The P2 Pro focuses on the general consumer market and electronic repair shops. Its compact and lightweight nature is an advantage in the former segment. The macro lens helps in determining locations of shorts or faulty components in small PCBs.

Both cameras use the same image sensor and USB bridge / microcontroller. The availability of publicly documented APIs for the TOPDON TC001 results in the same being applicable to the InfiRay P2 Pro also. Even without those APIs, the temperature storage format has been reverse-engineered, and a proof-of-concept open-source software interface is already available. There is no need to install closed-source software in order to access and analyze the recorded videos and photographs.

While the image quality is excellent, and sensor size for the price is quite good, we are not entirely convinced by the accuracy of temperature measurements under automatic calibration. It is possible that tweaked emissivity settings may deliver better results, but we saw the FLIR ONE Pro under similar default conditions deliver much more accurate results. This is an aspect that needs further investigation. That said, most consumer thermal camera applications require the observation of temperature gradients rather than the absolute values. For such use-cases, thermal cameras such as the InfiRay P2 Pro and the TOPDON TC001 provide excellent value for money in the $200 – $300 price bracket.

Another aspect that deserves mention prior to wrap up is the availability of 25 Hz thermal camera videos at very affordable price points for the consumer market. US-based manufacturers such as FLIR and Seek Thermal may need to work on getting past the artificially-imposed 9 Hz limitation if they are to remain competitive against the offerings from IRay Technologies in the global market.


Source link

Latest stories